Delmonico’s is more than just a great restaurant; it’s a generous slice of New York City history. Abraham Lincoln dined here, and Mark Twain celebrated his 70th birthday here. There is certainly no shortage of history within these walls!

We didn’t realize just how large the restaurant was until we arrived. We were seated in a back room behind the bar, which had a lovely ambiance and made for a comfortable, enjoyable evening.

From start to finish, this was a fantastic steakhouse experience. The staff was attentive, friendly, knowledgeable, and professional, making us feel well taken care of throughout the evening.

We started with the Chilled Jumbo Prawns with Cocktail Sauce, which were very good, followed by the Caesar Salad with Little Gem lettuce, aged Parmesan, anchovy, and creamy Myung Ran dressing. Excellent!

The Maine Crab Cake, served with potato strings and tarragon dill tartar sauce, was an absolute standout. Quite possibly the best crab cake I’ve ever had!

For our main course, we ordered the 36oz Porterhouse for Two from DemKota Ranch in South Dakota. It was cooked to perfection, with the temperature exactly as requested. The accompanying sauces, including shallot beef jus, horseradish cream, and peppercorn, complemented the steak beautifully. The quality of the meat and the execution were outstanding.

We paired it with several sides:

  • Crispy Brussels Sprouts with wasabi aioli and Bubu Arare – delicious.
  • Creamed Spinach with garlic béchamel – a great choice.
  • Delmonico’s Potatoes, a crispy potato mille-feuille with crème fraîche and chives – very good.
  • Mashed Potatoes – wonderfully creamy and excellent.

Everything was prepared beautifully, and every dish delivered.

We finished the evening with Pumpkin Pie served with sweet crème fraîche. Quite possibly the best pumpkin pie I’ve ever had! A perfect ending to a wonderful meal.

The wine selection was impressive, and the bar offered an excellent selection of cocktails. Between the food, atmosphere, attentive service, and rich history, Delmonico’s delivered a memorable dining experience.

We’ll definitely be back!

Overall Rating: 9.2/10

Author

Write A Comment

Published comments show your name. See the Privacy Policy.